Comparison
Trade Ideas vs Trade Copilot
Trade Ideas is a powerful AI scanner for US stocks — its Holly AI hunts the equity market overnight and hands you trade ideas with entries, stops and targets. Trade Copilot is the AI for your crypto account — it connects read-only to your exchanges, reads your live positions, and works the trades you actually place. A market scanner for stocks vs. an AI that knows your own book.
TL;DR
Trade Ideas is one of the best-known AI scanners for US equities: 40+ real-time scans plus the Holly AI engine, which back-tests historical patterns overnight and surfaces a morning watchlist of stock setups with entry, stop and target — and can even auto-trade them through a connected brokerage. It is built to answer “which stock should I trade today?” Trade Copilot answers a different question entirely. It connects read-only to Binance, Bybit, OKX, Coinbase and Hyperliquid (including perps), reads your live positions and fills, learns your strategy from your Library, and journals every trade — so it is about how you manage your own crypto book, not which equity to scan for next. Different market, different job.
How Trade Copilot and Trade Ideas compare
| Feature | Trade Copilot | Trade Ideas |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | The AI that knows your trading, wired into your accounts | AI scanner that surfaces stock trade ideas |
| Market | Crypto — spot and perps across five exchanges | US equities (stocks) |
| The question it answers | “How should I manage what I'm trading?” | “Which stock should I trade today?” |
| Connects to your exchange accounts | Yes — read-only to Binance, Bybit, OKX, Coinbase, Hyperliquid | Links a stock brokerage for scanning/auto-trade |
| Sees your live positions, orders & fills | Yes, in real time across every connected exchange | No — it scans the market, not your open book |
| Knows your strategy & history | Yes — persistent Library plus auto-journaling | No — its focus is the market scan, not you |
| Generates trade ideas | Yes — crypto setup ideas on the symbol you pick, with entry, invalidation, stop, targets and risks | Yes — Holly's overnight stock ideas with entry, stop and target |
| Checks your setup before you enter | Grades it A/B/C/Reject against your own rules | No — it surfaces its own ideas; it doesn't check yours |
| Trade journaling & performance review | Every closed trade journaled; written review of closes that happen while the app is open (up to 5 a day), plus a weekly review | No — scanning and signals, not journaling |
| Auto-trading | Never — read-only, you place every trade | Optional via brokerage integration |
| Pricing | $49/mo, 7-day free trial | Paid tiers roughly $89–$228/mo |
Why traders choose Trade Copilot over Trade Ideas
It knows YOUR trading, not the market scan
Trade Ideas scans thousands of stocks to tell you what to buy. Trade Copilot brings your live positions, your Library rules, your history and your mistake patterns into every answer — so the help is about the crypto you're actually trading, not a watchlist of equities you've never touched.
It's built for crypto, including perps
Trade Ideas is a US-equities tool. Trade Copilot connects read-only to Binance, Bybit, OKX, Coinbase and Hyperliquid and understands spot and perpetual positions — the markets crypto day-traders actually live in.
It works the whole trade — and never trades for you
Daily brief, live bias and levels, a pre-trade rule check, auto-journaling and a weekly review. Holly can auto-execute its ideas on stocks; Trade Copilot is read-only and helps you decide, so you stay in control of every entry.
When Trade Ideas is the better fit
- You trade US stocks, not crypto — Trade Ideas scans the equity market Trade Copilot doesn't cover.
- You want an AI to pick which stock to trade from the whole market each morning.
- You want hands-off auto-execution of scanner setups through a brokerage.
These tools live in different markets. Trade Ideas scans the stock market for setups to trade; Trade Copilot works from your crypto account — ideas on the symbols you trade, your own rules, and review of the trades you place. An equity trader could use Trade Ideas; a crypto trader is the one Trade Copilot is built for.
Frequently asked questions
- Does Trade Ideas work for crypto?
- Trade Ideas is focused on US equities — its scans and Holly AI are built for the stock market. If you trade crypto, Trade Copilot is the better fit: it connects read-only to Binance, Bybit, OKX, Coinbase and Hyperliquid and works on your actual positions.
- Is Trade Copilot a scanner that finds trade ideas like Holly?
- No — it doesn't rank the market to pick which symbol you should trade. On a crypto symbol you choose, it can draft setup ideas — entry, invalidation, stop, targets and risks — for you to evaluate. Its centre is your own account: it reads your live positions and fills and helps you manage and review the trades you place.
- Does Trade Copilot auto-trade like Trade Ideas' brokerage integration?
- Never. Trade Copilot connects with read-only API keys, so it can see your positions, orders and fills but can never place, cancel or withdraw. You place every trade yourself; it analyzes and advises.
- Can I use Trade Ideas and Trade Copilot together?
- If you trade both stocks and crypto, yes — scan US equities with Trade Ideas, and manage and review your crypto trades with Trade Copilot. They cover different markets.
- Is Trade Copilot a good Trade Ideas alternative?
- For crypto, yes. If you specifically want an AI stock scanner that generates equity setups, Trade Ideas is purpose-built for that. If you want an AI that knows your own crypto positions, rules and history, Trade Copilot is the stronger choice.
- How much does Trade Copilot cost?
- Trade Copilot is $49/mo and starts with a 7-day free trial. Trade Ideas runs roughly $89–$228/mo depending on tier and Holly access. See the pricing page for more details.
Compare Trade Copilot with other tools
- ChatGPT
- 3Commas
- TradeZella
- Pionex
- Cryptohopper
- Bitsgap
- Coinrule
- Token Metrics
- TraderSync
- Edgewonk
- TradingView AI
- Claude + TradingView MCP
- Perplexity Finance
- Tickeron
- Incite AI
- TrendSpider
- Composer
- Danelfin
New to AI trading assistants? See AI for trading, the supported exchanges, or browse all comparisons.